Humility is a Strange Thing Quote Origin & Meaning

“Humility is a strange thing. The moment you think you’ve got it, you’ve lost it.”

Explore More About E. D. Hulse

If you’re interested in learning more about E. D. Hulse and their impact on history, here are some recommended resources:

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Who First Said This Quote

This powerful paradox captures a fundamental truth about the human condition. It speaks to a virtue that, by its very nature, cannot be consciously claimed. The moment you declare your own humility, you demonstrate a form of pride that instantly negates it. This clever observation has resonated for decades, appearing in books, sermons, and daily devotionals. However, the origin of “humility is a strange thing. the moment you think you’ve got it quote origin” is as elusive as the quality it describes.

Many people attribute the quote to Sir Edward Hulse, a British physician. Yet extensive investigation reveals no concrete evidence connecting him to the phrase. This popular attribution seems to be a case of historical confusion. Over time, the quote’s journey has proven far more complex and interesting, winding through anonymous publications and evolving across decades. Understanding the true origins of “humility is a strange thing. the moment you think you’ve got it quote origin” requires us to trace this path carefully.

The Proverb’s True Ancestor

The conceptual framework for the quote appeared decades earlier than most realize. Its earliest known form emerged in 1925, but it discussed a different virtue entirely. Columnist Viola Brothers Shore published a piece called “Saws for the Goose” in several newspapers. In it, she wrote, “Gentility is a fairy gift. The minute you think you’ve got it you ain’t got it.” This version clearly provided the template for what would eventually become the more famous saying about humility. Source

What makes this discovery significant is how it demonstrates the evolution of popular wisdom. An idea starts in one context and is later adapted to fit another, more powerful one. The core paradox remains the same across both versions, but its application shifts dramatically. When the transition occurred from the social grace of gentility to the spiritual virtue of humility, it marked a significant step in the saying’s life and ultimate cultural resonance.

Humility Is a Strange Thing Meaning

From Gentility to Humility

By 1938, the phrase had transformed into its most recognizable form. In that year, the “Master Book of Humorous Illustrations,” compiled by Leewin B. Williams, included the quote. Crucially, the book offered no attribution whatsoever. It presented the wisdom as a piece of anonymous, common knowledge shared among educated readers. This anonymity helped the quote spread organically through popular culture, becoming a shared insight rather than the creation of a single author.

Soon after, the saying began appearing frequently in newspapers and publications across the country. In January 1939, “The Pittsburgh Courier” featured it among a list of weekly spiritual thoughts. Just a few months later, in April 1939, the “Ventura County Star-Free Press” in California printed the exact same wording in its “Daily Devotionals” section. This rapid circulation demonstrates the quote’s immediate and widespread appeal. Clearly, it struck a chord with a diverse audience searching for deeper insights about human nature.

Gaining Academic and Cultural Footing

The quote soon transcended casual newspaper columns and entered more scholarly works. In 1941, editors included the statement in “The Encyclopedia of Creative Thought” under its humility section. This placement lent it a new level of academic credibility and legitimacy. No longer merely a witty observation, it was now recognized wisdom worthy of serious compilation. As time went on, interest in “humility is a strange thing. the moment you think you’ve got it quote origin” grew among researchers and scholars alike.

As its popularity grew, variations and new attributions began to emerge. In November 1953, the entertainer Arthur Godfrey credited the sentiment to the famous columnist Walter Winchell. Godfrey’s profile by the Associated Press quoted him saying, “As Walter Winchell says, when you think you have it, you have lost it.” This highlights how people often attach anonymous wisdom to well-known figures, seeking to give it credible sourcing. Different versions appeared over time, sometimes substituting “minute” for “moment,” but the core message always remained intact.

Why This Quote Still Resonates Today

The Mystery of E. D. Hulse

The source of the modern attribution error can be traced to a specific publication. In February 1967, a magazine called “Quote: The Weekly Digest” attributed the saying to “E. D. Hulse.” This was likely a reference to a contributor from the “Bashford Methodist Messenger.” Over time, this attribution gained significant momentum when it was repeated in major publications. Both “The Wall Street Journal” and “Reader’s Digest” cited E. D. Hulse in 1967, further cementing the false attribution in popular culture.

Researchers investigating “humility is a strange thing. the moment you think you’ve got it quote origin” have discovered where the confusion likely began. Over the decades, the relatively unknown E. D. Hulse seems to have been mistaken for the more prominent Sir Edward Hulse. The similarity in names, combined with our natural tendency to associate wisdom with notable figures, probably fueled this error. Consequently, a mistaken attribution became entrenched in popular culture, persisting even in modern books and articles today.

The Enduring Power of a Paradox

Ultimately, the question of authorship is secondary to the quote’s enduring power and resonance. Its appeal lies in the fundamental psychological truth it reveals about human nature. True humility is an un-self-conscious state by definition. The act of recognizing and claiming it requires a level of self-focus that is inherently at odds with being humble. It is, in essence, a classic Catch-22.

This paradox is universal in its application. It transcends culture, religion, and time period. It reminds us that some virtues are lived rather than declared. The quote’s anonymous origins may be the most fitting tribute to its message. Exploring “humility is a strange thing. the moment you think you’ve got it quote origin” teaches us that claiming authorship of a famous quote about humility would be the ultimate irony. Its mysterious history ensures that the wisdom itself remains the focus, a timeless reminder to check our own pride.