“I Source Am a Fugitive From a Daisy Chain Gang”
The intersection of literary criticism and popular culture often produces moments of wit that transcend their original context. Such is the case with a clever piece of wordplay that emerged in the 1930s, linking a critically acclaimed film with a scathing review of contemporary literature.
The Cultural Backdrop
In 1932, Warner Brothers released “I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang,” a powerful drama that captivated audiences. The film portrayed the harrowing journey of an innocent man wrongfully imprisoned and his escape from brutal penal conditions. This cinematic success provided a rich foundation for a sharp-tongued critic to craft a parody title in response to perceived literary mediocrity.
The target of this literary critique was Tiffany Thayer, a writer whose work spanned genres like erotica and science fiction. Source Thayer became known for his unconventional approach, notably founding the Fortean Society in New York to explore unexplained phenomena. His provocative storytelling often pushed societal boundaries, as seen in his reinterpretation of classics .
The Scathing Review
One of Thayer’s novels, “An American Girl,” became the subject of a memorable review. Source A prominent critic delivered a harsh assessment, describing Thayer’s literary approach to sexuality with cutting precision. The review suggested that Thayer’s style rendered romantic themes unappealing, prompting readers to question their worth .
The review’s masterstroke lay in its alternative title suggestion, transforming the serious prison drama into a commentary on erotic literature. The critic proposed replacing the “pastel title” with the witty “I Am a Fugitive from a Daisy Chain Gang.” This wordplay critiqued the perceived quality and appeal of Thayer’s work.
The Legacy of the Review
Published in The New Yorker on March 18, 1933, under the pen name “Constant Reader,” this critique extended far beyond its initial appearance. Source The review gained renewed attention when compiled in a 1970 collection, ensuring its wit reached new audiences. The enduring appeal was further highlighted in biographical works about prominent literary figures of the era .
Leslie Frewin’s 1986 biography “The Late Mrs. Dorothy Parker” emphasized this review as an example of the sharp wit characterizing the critic’s approach. Despite Thayer’s success, the reviewer remained unimpressed, reflecting a critical view of contemporary literature.
Conclusion
The attribution of this memorable quip to Dorothy Parker reflects her reputation as a formidable literary critic. Her ability to craft devastating reviews with intellectual rigor and humor ensured this critique’s place in literary history. In summary, “I Am a Fugitive from a Daisy Chain Gang” remains a testament to the enduring power of literary wit.