In the world of Homeric epics, heroes chase glory, or kleos, on distant battlefields. Yet, a deeper, more powerful yearning often drives their journeys: the return home. This concept, known as nostos, is more than just a homecoming. It represents a return to one’s identity, family, and rightful place in the world. The home itself, the oikos, is the center of this world. It encompasses the physical house, family, property, and social standing. Homer’s epics, particularly The Odyssey, masterfully explore how displacement from the oikos threatens a hero’s very existence, making the quest for nostos a desperate fight for survival.
. Source
Odysseus: The Archetypal Struggle for Nostos
Odysseus is the ultimate embodiment of the struggle for nostos. For ten long years after the Trojan War, he wanders the seas, facing unimaginable perils. His journey is not a series of random adventures; instead, each obstacle is a direct threat to his homecoming. These dangers test his resolve and attempt to erase the memory of his home in Ithaca. For instance, the Lotus-Eaters offer a fruit that brings blissful forgetfulness, a tempting escape that would permanently sever his connection to his oikos. Similarly, the enchantress Circe and the nymph Calypso offer him comfort, pleasure, and even immortality. Calypso’s offer is particularly potent. She promises to make him a god, but Odysseus rejects it. He chooses his mortal life as a husband and father over a timeless, placeless existence. His identity is inextricably linked to his role within his household, and without it, even immortality is meaningless. This choice underscores the profound importance of oikos in the Homeric worldview. It is the anchor of human identity.
The Crumbling Oikos in Ithaca
Meanwhile, the peril of displacement is not Odysseus’s alone. His prolonged absence creates a power vacuum that devastates his home. Back in Ithaca, his oikos is in a state of collapse. A horde of arrogant suitors has overrun his palace. They consume his wealth, disrespect his son, Telemachus, and pressure his wife, Penelope, to remarry. This chaos demonstrates a core principle: the oikos cannot function without its head. Telemachus is unable to assert authority, and Penelope must resort to cunning tricks, like weaving and unweaving a burial shroud, to delay choosing a new husband. The suitors’ presence is a constant threat to the legitimacy and survival of Odysseus’s lineage. Consequently, their story is not just a subplot; it is the other half of the tragedy of displacement. It shows the societal decay that occurs when a leader is lost and the home is left unprotected.
Achilles: The Tragic Rejection of Nostos
In contrast to Odysseus, Achilles from The Iliad faces a different, yet equally profound, choice concerning his return home. He is given a direct prophecy about his fate. He can either return to his homeland of Phthia for a long, peaceful life devoid of fame, or he can stay and fight at Troy, guaranteeing a short life but eternal glory (kleos). Achilles ultimately chooses kleos over nostos. He sacrifices the comfort and stability of his oikos for a legacy that will outlive him. This decision presents a tragic alternative to the journey of Odysseus. It highlights the immense value placed on homecoming by showing what a hero must give up to reject it. While Odysseus fights to reclaim his identity through nostos, Achilles secures his identity by abandoning it. Homer thus presents two paths for a hero, both fraught with peril and sacrifice. Scholars have long debated these competing values in Greek culture. Source
. Homer’s Odyssey: A Hero’s Jour…
The Psychological Price of Being Lost
The physical dangers of displacement are obvious, but Homer delves deeper into the psychological toll. Agamemnon’s story serves as a dark cautionary tale. He successfully completes his nostos after the Trojan War, only to return to a corrupted oikos. His wife, Clytemnestra, has taken a lover and plots his murder. He arrives home not to a joyful reunion but to a brutal death. This horrific outcome subverts the entire ideal of homecoming, proving that the return itself does not guarantee safety. It shows that the oikos can become as dangerous as any monster faced on the sea. Furthermore, the loss of identity is a constant threat for the wandering hero. When Odysseus confronts the Cyclops Polyphemus, he cleverly calls himself “Noman” (Outis). While this trick saves his life, it also symbolizes the existential crisis of displacement. Far from home, stripped of his titles and recognition, he is literally a nobody. His entire journey is a fight to reclaim his name and the status that comes with it. This internal struggle is just as challenging as his external battles. In the end, the Homeric epics teach us that home is not merely a place. It is the source of meaning, order, and identity. To be displaced is to be unmade, and the fight to return is the fight to become whole again.