The opening sentence of Aristotle‘s Metaphysics is one of the most famous in all of philosophy. “All men by nature desire to know.” This simple declaration serves as the foundation for his entire philosophical project. However, it is not merely an isolated observation about human curiosity. Instead, this statement is a deliberate and powerful response to the major intellectual debates of his time. To truly understand its weight, we must explore the rich historical and philosophical context from which it emerged. Aristotle was not writing in a vacuum; he was engaging in a vibrant, ongoing conversation with his predecessors and contemporaries.
. Source
The World Before Aristotle: Pre-Socratic Inquiries
Long before Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy – Ar…, early Greek thinkers, now known as the Pre-Socratics, began a revolutionary shift. They moved away from mythological explanations of the world. Consequently, they sought rational, naturalistic accounts of reality. Philosophers like Thales, Anaximander, and Anaximenes searched for the arche, or the single underlying substance from which everything else comes. For Thales, it was water; for others, it was an indefinite substance or air.
Later, thinkers like Heraclitus argued that everything is in a constant state of flux, famously stating that one cannot step into the same river twice. In direct contrast, Parmenides contended that all change is an illusion. He believed that reality is one, eternal, and unchanging. These conflicting views created a significant philosophical problem. If reality is constantly changing, how can we have stable knowledge? Conversely, if reality is unchanging, how do we account for the world we experience with our senses? This fundamental tension set the stage for the next generation of philosophers, including Aristotle’s own teacher, Plato.
The Shadow of Plato and the World of Forms
Aristotle studied at Plato’s Academy for two decades, a formative experience that profoundly shaped his own philosophy. . Plato offered a radical solution to the problem of knowledge. He proposed that the physical world we perceive with our senses is not the real world. Instead, it is a mere shadow or imperfect copy of a higher, eternal reality: the world of Forms. Source
For Plato, true knowledge (episteme) could only be of these perfect, unchanging Forms—the ideal Form of a Triangle, the Form of Justice, the Form of the Good. We access this knowledge through reason and intellect, not through our unreliable senses. The famous allegory of the cave illustrates this perfectly. Prisoners mistake shadows on a wall for reality, unable to see the true objects (the Forms) casting them. Therefore, for a Platonist, the