“Education Isn’t Everything”
>
“You’re Right, For a Start It’s Not Elephants”
We often treat formal schooling as the ultimate answer to life’s problems. However, a legendary comedian once poked a hole in this assumption with a single, bizarre sentence. Spike Milligan, the master of British surrealist comedy, delivered this line to remind us of the limits of learning. He used his trademark wit to shatter our serious views on intelligence.
Specifically, the joke works because it is technically true yet completely ridiculous. Education is indeed not an elephant. Furthermore, it is not a toaster, a cloud, or a banana. By stating the obvious in an absurd way, Milligan forces us to laugh at the phrase “education isn’t everything.” This article explores the origins of this witty observation and why it remains relevant today.
Tracing the Quote to 1974
Many fans attribute this quote to stand-up routines or television interviews. Source However, the true origin lies in the written word. In this memoir, Milligan recounts his experiences during World War II with a heavy dose of absurdity.
The scene involves a character named Edgington. He watches a pilot fly a plane while shouting commands simultaneously. Edgington remarks on the pilot’s skills, implying he must have a good education. Consequently, the dialogue shifts to the now-famous punchline. In this original version, the response uses the plural word “elephants.”
Milligan published this book in the mid-70s. It captures the chaotic energy of his military service. Moreover, it showcases his ability to find humor in grim situations. The joke serves as a perfect example of his “Goon Show” style humor. It disrupts a logical conversation with sudden nonsense. Readers often pause here, struck by the sudden shift from war stories to zoological comparisons.
The Joke’s Second Life
Decades later, the joke resurfaced in a poignant context. Spike Milligan passed away in 2002. Interestingly, he had prepared for this moment long before it happened. In 1990, he wrote his own obituary for the Evening Standard.
When the newspaper published this self-penned tribute, it included a list of his favorite quips. This time, the phrasing changed slightly. The text read, “For a start it isn’t an elephant.” Thus, the plural became singular. This minor tweak makes the object seem even more specific and absurd.
Anthologies soon picked up the line. For instance, Geoff Tibballs included it in The Mammoth Book of Zingers. Rosemarie Jarski also featured it in her collection, Dim Wit. These publications cemented the quote’s status as a classic one-liner. They ensured new generations would encounter Milligan’s unique logic. As a result, the quote transitioned from a hidden gem in a memoir to a widely recognized proverb of nonsense.
Deconstructing the Absurdity
Why does this specific line make us laugh? Primarily, it relies on a linguistic trick called a “category error.” We expect a philosophical counterpoint about experience or wisdom. Instead, we get a large mammal.
The brain anticipates a logical conclusion. When Milligan swaps a concept for a concrete object, it creates a mental jolt. Furthermore, the statement is undeniably factual. Nobody can argue that education is an elephant. This factual accuracy makes the stupidity of the statement even funnier.
Additionally, it mocks the seriousness of intellectual debates. People often use the phrase “education isn’t everything” to sound profound. Milligan strips away that profundity. He reduces the argument to its literal components. As a result, he highlights the pretentiousness of the original statement. It serves as a reminder that deep thoughts do not always require deep words.
The Master of Nonsense
Spike Milligan did not just tell jokes; he reshaped comedy. He served as the primary creative force behind The Goon Show. This radio program influenced comedy giants like Monty Python. His style relied heavily on this type of surrealism.
He viewed the world through a distorted lens. To Milligan, the rules of logic were merely suggestions. Consequently, comparing abstract concepts to zoo animals felt perfectly natural. This quote captures his worldview perfectly. It refuses to play by the rules of standard conversation.
We still quote him today because his humor cuts through the noise. In a world obsessed with credentials and degrees, his voice remains refreshing. He reminds us not to take our institutions too seriously. After all, a degree is valuable, but you cannot ride it across the savanna. His legacy lives on through these small, perfect moments of confusion.
Conclusion
Spike Milligan left us with a treasure trove of laughter. This specific quote stands out as a prime example of his genius. It started in a war memoir and ended up in his own obituary. Through it all, the joke remained sharp, silly, and surprisingly memorable.
Education certainly has value. It opens doors and expands minds. However, we must remember its limitations. As Milligan so helpfully pointed out, it will never be a pachyderm. Therefore, we should appreciate learning for what it is, without confusing it for what it is not.